Best Alabama White Sauce in 2023

Are you trapped in a barbecue sauce rut, yearning for a tangy twist to rejuvenate your grilling game? Feast your eyes and ignite your culinary curiosity with the Alabama White BBQ Sauce, a delectably creamy, zesty concoction that’s set to become your new secret weapon. Beyond its traditional red counterpart, this ivory-hued elixir promises a gastronomic adventure that will take your barbecue repertoire to new, smoky heights. Dive into our enticing round-up post and unveil the mysteries behind this Southern hidden gem. Spoiler alert: it might just make your taste buds do the cha-cha! Let’s journey together into the heart of Alabama’s best-kept barbecue secret.

What Are the Best Alabama White Sauces?

Ah, the time-honored quest for the crème de la crème of Alabama White BBQ sauces. Among the array of delightful bottled renditions, three stand out for their outstanding flavor profiles, rave reviews, and faithful homage to the original recipe. Allow me to present them in the order of reverence.

FIRST PLACE	SECOND PLACE	THIRD PLACE
Big Bob Gibson’s Original White Sauce: A rightful occupant of the top position, this sauce is an authentic reproduction of the legendary concoction pioneered by Big Bob Gibson himself. It marries a creamy base with a well-rounded tang, striking a delectable balance that elevates any barbecued meat.	Duce’s Whiled Alabama White Gold BBQ Sauce: With its enchanting blend of creamy, tangy, and subtly spicy elements, Duce’s Whiled Alabama White Gold BBQ Sauce has secured a solid second place. Its rich and velvety texture, coupled with a touch of contemporary flair, makes it a crowd-pleaser.	Lillie’s Q – Ivory Barbeque Sauce: Clinching the third position is Lillie’s Q – Ivory Barbeque Sauce. It stands out with its mellifluous notes of sweet pickles, which add a unique, nuanced layer of flavor to the traditional Alabama white BBQ sauce base.

Each of these sauces offers a unique interpretation of the Alabama White BBQ Sauce, and your personal preference might align with any one of them. The true joy is in the journey of tasting and discovering your own favorite. Happy barbecuing!

1. Duce’s Wild Alabama White Gold Barbecue Sauce

Overview

Duce’s Wild Alabama White Gold Barbecue Sauce is an exquisite concoction that marries the age-old Southern barbecue tradition with a touch of modern flair. This Alabama white barbecue sauce is a velvety, rich delight that promises to take your barbecuing experience to new, tantalizing heights.

Key Benefits

• Infused with a balanced blend of rich, creamy elements and a subtle kick of spice.

• Pays homage to the traditional Southern barbecue style.

• Offers a versatile pairing with a range of grilled or smoked meats.

• Adds a contemporary touch to the time-honored BBQ sauce repertoire.

Pricing

Priced at $14.49, Duce’s Wild Alabama White Gold Barbecue Sauce provides exceptional value, given its rich flavor profile and premium quality.

Pros & Cons

Pros:

• Its rich and velvety texture amplifies the flavor of your barbecue.

• Delivers a subtle kick of spice that teases the palate without being overwhelming.

Cons:

• Some barbecue enthusiasts might find the contemporary flair deviating slightly from the traditional flavor profile they are accustomed to.

• The pricing might be a tad steep for casual barbecuers, although the unique flavor experience justifies the cost.

BUY IN AMAZON

2. Big Bob Gibson Original White Sauce

Overview

Big Bob Gibson Original Alabama White BBQ Sauce is a truly faithful homage to the iconic original white sauce that started it all. Masterfully crafted, this sauce offers a sublime blend of creaminess and a tangy sauce, celebrating the simplicity and purity of the legendary recipe.

Key Benefits

• Faithful recreation of the legendary original white sauce recipe.
• Delivers a perfectly balanced flavor profile, with creaminess and tang in harmony.
• An excellent accompaniment to a wide array of barbecued meats.
• Pays tribute to the genesis of the white BBQ sauce tradition.

Pricing

At $11.58 for a 16 oz. bottle, Big Bob Gibson Original White Sauce offers a taste of history at an affordable price point, providing a sublime blend of quality and value.

Pros & Cons

Pros:

• Offers a genuine taste of the original white BBQ sauce, representing the true Alabama tradition.
• The balanced flavor profile adds a versatile touch to various barbecued dishes.

Cons:

• As it is a faithful recreation of the original, it may lack the modern twists that some contemporary barbecue enthusiasts seek.
• Its simplicity, while a strong point, might not appeal to those who prefer a more complex flavor profile.

BUY IN AMAZON

3. Full Moon White BBQ Sauce

Overview

Just like a luminous night under the full moon, Full Moon White BBQ Sauce presents an enchanting blend of flavors that encapsulates pure culinary joy. This sauce delivers a symphony of tangy, spicy, and sweet notes, all while maintaining a rich, velvety texture that elevates any dish it graces.

Key Benefits

• Offers a vibrant blend of tangy, spicy, and sweet flavors.
• Features a smooth, velvety texture that coats your food beautifully.
• Serves as a versatile addition to smoked or grilled meats and various side dishes.
• The sauce’s rich flavor profile makes it a great dipping sauce.

Pricing

At $24.99 for a bundle of two 16-ounce bottles along with a JFS Recipe Card, Full Moon White BBQ Sauce provides an elevated barbecue experience that justifies its premium price point.

Pros & Cons :

Pros:

• The vibrant blend of flavors adds a new dimension to any barbecue dish.
• Its versatility makes it a great addition to both main courses and sides.

Cons:

• The higher price point may be a deterrent for some, although the unique, rich flavor profile and bundled recipe card offer added value.
• The blend of tangy, spicy, and sweet flavors, while exciting, might not appeal to purists who prefer a traditional white BBQ sauce.

BUY IN AMAZON

4. June Moon Alabama White BBQ Sauce

Overview

June Moon Alabama White BBQ Sauce encapsulates the sweetness of a Southern summer evening in every bottle. Infused with the luscious warmth of honey, this mildly flavored sauce is a perfect introduction for those venturing into the world of white barbecue sauces. Think of it as a delightful alternative to your regular ketchup or tomato-based sauces.

Key Benefits

• Features a creamy, slightly sweet, and tangy flavor profile with a hint of deep BBQ flavor.
• Offers versatility as a pairing for wings, chicken, turkey, or any BBQ dish.
• Serves as an excellent dipping sauce, elevating even the simplest of dishes.
• Freshness is guaranteed with a double seal applied immediately after blending.
• Presented in a sturdy 12 fluid ounce BPA free bottle with a reusable screw flavor lock top.

Pricing

Priced at $11.88, June Moon Alabama White BBQ Sauce provides a gentle, flavorful introduction to the world of white BBQ sauces without breaking the bank.

Pros & Cons:

Pros:

• The mild and balanced flavor profile serves as a versatile addition to a wide range of dishes.
• Freshness is maintained with a double seal, ensuring maximum flavor and zest.

Cons:

• While the gentle flavors are perfect for those new to Alabama White BBQ Sauce, they might lack the boldness preferred by seasoned BBQ enthusiasts.
• Though it’s a versatile sauce, its sweetness might not complement all types of meats, depending on individual taste preferences.

BUY IN AMAZON

5. The Tailgate Foodie’s White Lightning

Overview

The Tailgate Foodie’s White Lightning, a thrilling blend of creamy, tangy, and spicy elements, is as exhilarating as a lightning bolt. This audacious sauce promises a flavor-packed adventure, sparking your senses and leaving you yearning for more. Crafted in small batches and perfect for various dishes, this sauce adds a robust flavor that takes your grilling, smoking, or cooking experience to electrifying heights.

Key Benefits

• A striking blend of creamy, tangy, and spicy elements that awakens the senses.
• Handcrafted in small batches to ensure optimum flavor.
• Highly versatile and perfect for grilling, smoking, or cooking a variety of meats and seafood.
• Offers a variety of flavors for all, from sweet and vinegary to bold and spicy.
• Comes in a handy squeeze bottle for easy and controlled application.

Pricing

Priced at $12.99 for a 13.75-ounce bottle, The Tailgate Foodie’s White Lightning offers an adventurous gastronomic experience that justifies its premium price tag.

Pros & Cons:

Pros:

• Its audacious flavor profile makes it an exciting choice for those seeking an adventure in taste.
• The squeeze bottle design allows for easy, controlled application, eliminating the need for messy brushes or dripping bottles.

Cons:

• Its bold flavor might be a bit overwhelming for those who prefer a gentler, more traditional BBQ sauce.
• While its premium price tag aligns with its high-quality flavor profile, it may be a consideration for those on a tight budget.

As a small business with a passionate dedication to the art of BBQ, The Tailgate Foodie delivers not only an outstanding product but also an opportunity to support small businesses and enjoy a unique, handcrafted barbecue experience. Brace yourself for the electric embrace of White Lightning at your next cookout, tailgate, or family gathering. It’s not just a sauce; it’s an experience.

BUY IN AMAZON

6. Lillie’s Q – Ivory Barbeque Sauce

Overview

Lillie’s Q – Ivory Barbeque Sauce is a symphony of culinary artistry that resonates with Alabama’s barbecue heritage traditions while harmoniously integrating innovative twists. Conceived by revered pitmaster and chef Charlie McKenna, this sauce exhibits a balance of smooth creaminess, tang, and spice, truly embodying the essence of a white barbecue sauce. With zero sugar and a pinch of cayenne, it’s a tangy delight of white barbeque sauce that honors its roots while daring to be different.

Key Benefits

• Crafted with high-quality, gluten-free ingredients, ensuring a premium BBQ experience.
• Zero sugar, making it a healthier choice without sacrificing flavor.
• Balances traditional and innovative elements, perfect for grilling chicken and fries.
• Each bottle tells a unique story that’s rooted in regional tradition.

Pricing

At $22.90 for a 2-pack of 17-ounce bottles, Lillie’s Q – Ivory Barbeque Sauce offers an authentic taste of the South, all while maintaining a balance of quality and value.

Pros & Cons :

Pros:

• Its authentic flavor, stemming from a family lineage of BBQ passion, offers a genuine taste of Southern BBQ.
• The sauce is gluten-free and sugar-free, making it a healthier choice for barbecue enthusiasts.

Cons:

• While the innovative touch to traditional white BBQ sauce might appeal to some, purists might prefer a more classic flavor profile.
• Although justified by its premium ingredients and unique flavor, the higher price point might be slightly steep for some.

BUY IN AMAZON

7. Meat Mitch White Sauce

Overview

Bursting with robust flavors and creamy goodness, Meat Mitch White Sauce is a call to all barbecue enthusiasts to elevate their grilling game. This sauce invites you to be bold, to drench your chicken (or any other meat for that matter) in its rich blend of ingredients. The ultimate replacement for plain old ranch dressing, this sauce carries an intriguing flavor profile that’s sure to add an extra punch to your meal.

Key Benefits

• Boasts a rich blend of flavors including horseradish, brown sugar, cayenne pepper, lemon juice, and vinegar.
• Provides a creamy texture that evenly coats your meal for an enhanced flavor experience.
• Versatile use: dunk, drizzle, slather, bathe or apply as per your culinary heart’s desire.
• Serves as an excellent alternative to traditional condiments like ranch dressing.

Pricing

At $15.00, Meat Mitch White Sauce brings a punch of complex flavors to your table, offering excellent value for the price.

Pros & Cons

Pros:

• The sauce’s robust and complex flavors add an intriguing twist to any barbecue dish.
• Its creamy texture allows for versatile application and evenly coats your food for maximum flavor.

Cons:

• Given the strong flavor profile, this sauce might not be for everyone, especially those who prefer a milder sauce.
• While it’s a delightful alternative to ranch dressing, those with a strong preference for traditional condiments might find the transition a bit daring.

BUY IN AMAZON

8. Hi-Tone White BBQ Sauce

Overview

Hi-Tone White BBQ Sauce is a delectable fusion of Eastern and Western BBQ spices, packed with the zest of vinegar and lemon. This sauce is a tantalizing combination of mayonnaise, apple cider vinegar, and fresh lemon juice, culminating in an unforgettable gastronomic experience. Designed for barbecue enthusiasts who appreciate a bit of funk in their food, it’s a handcrafted marvel straight from the heart of the Delta.

Key Benefits

• Delivers a symphony of flavors without overpowering the natural taste of the dish.
• Its unique blend of Eastern and Western BBQ spices provides an exciting twist to traditional BBQ flavors.
• Can be used with a variety of dishes like chicken wings, turkey, salmon, ribs, and seafood.
• Crafted with premium, all-natural ingredients, it’s free from gluten, MSG, high fructose corn syrup, and fillers.
• Comes in a 12.5-ounce bottle, offering ample quantity for several BBQ sessions.

Pricing

For $15.99, you get 12.5 ounces of Hi-Tone White BBQ Sauce, a premium, handcrafted BBQ sauce that promises to transport your taste buds to a new world of BBQ flavors.

Pros & Cons:

Pros:

• The unique blend of Eastern and Western spices adds a unique twist to traditional BBQ dishes.
• It’s versatile and can be used with a variety of dishes.

Cons:

• The unique flavor profile might not appeal to everyone, especially those who prefer traditional BBQ flavors.
• The price might seem a bit steep for a BBQ sauce, but the unique flavors and quality ingredients justify the cost.

BUY IN AMAZON

What Is Alabama White Sauce?

Alabama white sauce, or white barbecue sauce, is a regionally unique style of barbecue sauce that originated in northern Alabama. Its primary ingredients are mayonnaise, apple cider vinegar, and pepper, resulting in a tangy, creamy sauce that’s quite different from the thicker, sweeter, and more tomato-based barbecue sauces common in other parts of the United States.

The Alabama white sauce was first introduced by Robert Gibson at Big Bob Gibson’s Bar-B-Q in Decatur, Alabama, around 1925. Unlike traditional BBQ sauces, the Alabama white sauce has a distinctly tangy flavor that perfectly complements the smokiness of barbecued meats, especially the smoked chicken wings and turkey. But it doesn’t stop there. This versatile condiment is also a delicious addition to burgers, smoked chicken, seafood, and vegetables and can even be used as a salad dressing.

Despite being less widely known outside the Southern United States, Alabama white bbq sauce has gained recognition and popularity for its unique and versatile flavor profile. Once you’ve tried it, it might just become your new favorite barbecue condiment!

How Can Alabama White Sauce Benefit Your BBQ?

Alabama white barbecue sauce is more than just an appealing addition to your culinary repertoire. It’s an experience, a delightful detour from the traditional barbecue sauce landscape that can genuinely refresh and diversify your palette.

Firstly, it’s incredibly versatile. It complements dishes beyond grilled meats, including vegetables, seafood, salads, and sandwiches. This adaptability can encourage you to experiment more in the kitchen, venturing beyond the conventional applications of traditional barbecue sauce recipes. Your family dinners, barbecue parties, or even solo food explorations can gain a new layer of flavor exploration.

Lastly, if you’re mindful of what goes into your food, the simplicity of the Alabama white sauce might be a welcome characteristic. The primary ingredients – mayonnaise, apple cider vinegar, and pepper – are kitchen staples that you likely already have at home. For the health-conscious, opting to create your homemade version of this sauce allows you to control the quality of the ingredients, reducing preservatives and added sugars found in some store-bought versions. It’s a win for your taste buds and your health, a benefit worth considering.

Buyers Guide: How We Conducted Our Researched 

In our quest to provide you with the most comprehensive and reliable information about Alabama white barbecue sauces, we adhered to a structured research methodology. We aimed to balance various factors, ensuring we consider a product’s overall value, not just its price or a single feature. Here’s a glimpse into our research process:

1. Product Selection: We started by gathering a broad range of products, including those with varying price points and features. We included sauces from both established brands and new players.

2. Pricing Evaluation: For each product, we analyzed the cost, taking into account the volume of sauce in each bottle. We sought to understand the price range in the market and identify sauces that deliver excellent value for their cost.

3. Feature Analysis: We studied the list of ingredients, the flavor profile, and the versatility of each sauce. We also considered other features like packaging design, which can impact user experience, particularly when it comes to dispensing the sauce.

4. Negatives Identification: No product is perfect, and Alabama white BBQ sauces are no exception. We looked for potential shortcomings, such as a flavor profile that might not appeal to everyone, or less healthy ingredients like high fructose corn syrup.

5. Refund Policy and Support: We investigated whether companies offer a refund policy if customers are dissatisfied with their purchase. We also considered the presence of customer support, which could be essential if a buyer has questions or issues with their product.

6. Customer Reviews: We delved into customer reviews and ratings for each product to gain insights into real-world usage. These reviews can reveal strengths and weaknesses that aren’t apparent in product descriptions.

7. Final Evaluation: After gathering all this information, we weighed the pros and cons of each sauce, factoring in the balance of price, features, potential negatives, and customer feedback.

Our goal through this process was to provide you with a well-rounded understanding of the best Alabama white BBQ sauces on the market, enabling you to make an informed choice that suits your taste and budget.

Wrapping Up

And there you have it, dear readers, a grand tour of the tantalizing world of Alabama white BBQ sauce – a journey through the valleys of vinegar, peaks of black pepper, and meadows of mayonnaise. We’ve waltzed around the barbecue, paid our respects to the original maestro Big Bob Gibson, and marinated ourselves in the rich, tangy history of this often underappreciated condiment.

But why, you may ask, should you listen to Me? Well, besides the fact that I’ve practically been baptized in BBQ sauce and have spent more hours studying these concoctions than I’d like to admit, I’m just like you. I’m on a perpetual quest for that perfect grill companion, that saucy siren, that creamy dream that sends our taste buds twirling. And if there’s a shortcut to BBQ nirvana, you can bet your basting brush we’re going to take it.

So, whether you’re a pit master in pursuit of your next secret ingredient or a curious foodie ready to plunge into a new culinary adventure, we hope our saucy escapades have kindled a flame of interest for the Alabama white BBQ sauce. Remember, in the realm of barbecue, the sauce is the boss. Choose wisely, live freely, and always keep your apron within arm’s reach. Until next time, keep those grills sizzling and the sauce drizzling!

FAQ

J.L.  Surjan

A humble barbecue connoisseur and Alabama White BBQ Sauce devotee

Disclosure: Our blog contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links. However, this does not impact our reviews and comparisons. We try our best to keep things fair and balanced, in order to help you make the best choice for you.